GDTS noted that it was 50% chance for MSG and Syracuse for those postmarked the first day. Total bummer. I'm awaiting the news myself (and am surprised that you've heard so soon).
Ticketbastard still has plenty of tix (at least when I just looked...in the 100s at least).
Sorry to hear that too. It sucks. A friend told me they increased the allotment of MSG tickets GDTSTOO got, obviously not enough. If ticketbasterd runs out, there will be MSG tickets for sale on secondary markets, just luck early for heads selling tickets on craigslist (or here). As it gets closer it's hit or miss.
I assume you followed all mail order "rules" - name of venue & # of tickets on outside of envelope, #10 envelopes (one self addressed, both with postage), (postal ?) money order, 3X5 index card and maybe most important...hand postmarked at the post office.
I only mention this because I have a friend who thought GDTSTOO had him on their shit list, but after the second rejection we realized he was not mailing per the instructions.