Well, I just saw them play in 2010 - again - as I have been doing for 37 years. Still the same 5 guys that began together 41 years ago. Sure, an argument can be made that their new music (of the past 25 years sucks), that they (Tyler especially) are sellouts (American Idol which I have never even seen) and that they are in it only for the money.
Myself, I don't deny this point of view or even try and counter argue.
However, I am just mighty glad and thankful that they are all 5 still alive and playing together. And, if you think they don't rock still, you need to go to a show and find out for yourself.
If it is simply a matter of what IS and IS NOT considered cool, you win. I don't care about what's considered cool anymore.